As a fundraising trainer for 30-plus years, I’ve noticed that some topics never go away. Among the greatest hits:
- Helping nonprofit boards learn how to raise money.
- Getting over the fear of fundraising.
- Diversifying income and creating a more resilient revenue model.
- Major gifts: Asking for big gifts face to face.
Other subjects rise and fall, depending on who’s in the room, the state of the economy, advances in technology, the political environment, etc.
For example, when people ask for fundraising database recommendations, I encourage them to crowdsource answers from their peers – which is how I sidestep the question.
Today, I want to discuss one of those nagging questions that comes up during the Q&A: “Should our nonprofit be a membership organization?”
For most askers, the question translates as follows: “Should we call our donors members? What are the pros and cons?”
“Membership” means at least three things
Let’s start with definitions, because the word membership is inherently confusing.
Definition 1: Members contribute money. In this instance, member = donor = supporter. In some cases, members/donors receive specific benefits, such priority access to events. A lot of cultural and site-based organizations (theaters, museums, botanical gardens, historic houses, etc.) use the word member in this way.
Definition 2: Members contribute money and vote for the leadership. In some organizations, members contribute financially and elect the board of directors, as specified in the bylaws. The goal of this model is to deepen member/donor engagement and create a kind of nonprofit democracy.
One example: the Sierra Club, whose board elections are often competitive and therefore promote member engagement.

Definition 3: Members contribute money, vote for the leadership, and are encouraged (even expected) to be actively involved. This is the most ambitious definition, because membership assumes a commitment of time and energy, in addition to money.
Your neighborhood religious congregation – church, mosque, synagogue, temple, etc. – uses this kind of membership model. Many community organizing groups (some of which are grounded in faith communities) use the same approach.
When I’m asked about membership, I often respond, “Which kind of membership are we talking about?”
Why use the word – and why not
On one hand, membership connotes ownership and connection. If you’re a member, you belong to the organization and, conversely, it belongs to you. When recruiting and renewing donors, that sense of belonging is a powerful draw.

On the other hand, not everyone wants to belong. As a door-to-door canvasser (my first fundraising job!) in the 1980s, I would pitch membership in our community-based social justice group. Some people would decline by saying, “I’m not a joiner.” For them, “belonging” felt like a commitment they were unable or unwilling to make.
In response, I might propose – with occasional success – a non-membership donation as a show of solidarity.
Treat everyone like family
Clearly, the word “member” has no magical powers. Words alone do not create a sense of ownership or participation.

Regardless of what you call your donors, treat them as valued partners. Your success is their success. Your struggles are theirs, too.
Without excessively centering and catering to your donors (see Who is Your Fundraising About?), you can create an inclusive community where everyone – staff, board, program participants, partners, allies, and yes, financial supporters – feels that they belong.
As you build your community, you’ll discover the right language that works for you.
Leave a Comment